Our Story

Since 1944, our flagship company, Wick’s Pies, has been baking up delightful pies to share with Hoosiers around the world. Our most-loved pie, Sugar Cream, is not too sweet, yet creamy and satisfying. The one thing that makes it even better? A good cup of coffee – enter our friends at The Caffeinery in Muncie, Indiana.

Together, we concocted a blend of coffee beans that every pie lover could enjoy. Now that’s a match made in heaven (ope…a match made in small-town Indiana, actually).